When outreach gets no replies, the email usually takes the blame. More often the problem started earlier, because nobody stopped to ask whether the idea was newsworthy for the journalists receiving it.
The outreach chapter of our book, The Digital PR Playbook, starts with that question. Before it says anything about subject lines or follow-ups, it asks whether the idea is newsworthy and gives five checks to answer it. The book describes them as the points our team works through before any outreach.
Why the question comes first
Cambridge Dictionary defines newsworthy as “interesting enough to be described in a news report”. That sounds like a low bar until you look at a journalist’s inbox. In Muck Rack’s State of Journalism 2026 survey of 1,044 journalists, 14% said they received more than 20 pitches on their last normal working day, and 43% said the pitches they get are seldom relevant to what they cover.
Journalists don’t spend long deciding. In the same survey, 88% said they immediately disregard a pitch that doesn’t match their coverage area. Most of the people surveyed work in the US, with others in the UK, Canada and India, so treat the exact figures with some care. We see the same pattern in our own outreach to UK journalists.
of journalists immediately disregard a pitch that doesn’t match the area they cover.
Muck Rack, State of Journalism 2026of journalists say the pitches they receive are seldom relevant to what they cover.
Muck Rack, State of Journalism 2026The five checks
In our experience an idea rarely passes all five. It should pass at least one of them clearly, and each extra one it passes tends to open up more publications.
1. Timing. Is this the right moment? The chapter’s examples are a response to the latest inflation figures and expert comment on a trend that is taking off on TikTok. Sent too late, the same idea is old news. Timing also covers the calendar, and our post on Christmas product PR shows how search data can tell you when people will be looking.
2. Impact. Who does it affect, and how many of them? The book’s point is about reach. An idea that matters to a wide audience can go to more publications, which gives it more chances of coverage. If it only matters to a small group, send it to the publications that group reads.
3. Location. The chapter calls this the check people most often overlook. City and hyper-local news sites want ideas that are personal to their readers. A common way to get there is to break national data down by region or city, so each local publication gets figures about its own area. Muck Rack’s survey supports the point. 78% of journalists said a pitch feels genuinely relevant when it directly affects the community their audience belongs to, and 45% look for clear local or cultural context.
of journalists say a pitch feels genuinely relevant when it directly affects the community their audience belongs to.
Muck Rack, State of Journalism 20264. Conflict and controversy. Readers like a disagreement, whether it’s about a reality TV show, a royal mishap or a government announcement. An expert who disagrees with the accepted view, and can explain why, gives a journalist something to write about. We’d add one caution. Only take a position the business is happy to defend in public.
5. Weird and wonderful. Unusual things get read and shared, and the book’s examples are pimple-popping videos and TikTok challenges. For a brand, the equivalent is usually a surprising finding in its own data, or an odd fact about its product or customers that nobody has reported before.
Match the email to the idea
Once an idea passes, the chapter’s next step is to choose the right kind of outreach email. It sets out five formats, and the right one depends on the idea and the journalist.
For breaking news, include everything the journalist needs to write the article quickly, and say exactly which news you are responding to. A collaborative email suits long-lead work such as thought leadership. It introduces the brand and suggests a few ideas you can support with research, interviews or exclusive comment. An exclusive goes to one publication and should explain what you can provide and why its readers will care. The book describes this as a long-lead approach that helps reach journalists at publications such as The Telegraph and The Guardian.
A product review email should leave out sales language and give the journalist the launch details, the offer and the key figures. That matches the survey, where 71% of journalists said they delete pitches that feel overly promotional. A reactive email, for reactive PR (expert comment on the day’s news), should include tips, expert comment and research, plus a line on why the subject matters to the journalist’s readers right now. Our post on using your internal experts covers where that comment can come from.
If the idea doesn’t pass
Sometimes the honest answer is that the idea isn’t newsworthy yet. That is useful to know before outreach starts, while there is still time to change the idea. Go back through the checks. Could the data be broken down by region? Is there a date in the calendar it could tie to? Does someone in the business hold a view that others would argue with? If none of that works, the idea may suit the brand’s own blog or social channels better than outreach to journalists.
If you are planning outreach in the US, our older post on the dos and don’ts of pitching to US journalists adds a few things to check there.
Where AI search fits
The book was written before AI search became part of how people look things up. Coverage in publications people trust is now also among the sources AI tools draw on, and Muck Rack’s May 2026 study found that most of the links AI answers cite come from earned media. We wouldn’t promise that a newsworthy campaign gets a brand into an AI answer, because nobody can. The first job is the same either way, which is to give journalists an idea they want to cover.
If you’d like a team to run these checks on your next campaign and handle the outreach, have a look at our digital PR services. The full chapter, including subject lines, personalisation and follow-ups, is in The Digital PR Playbook.




