Choosing a digital PR agency is hard for one simple reason: you’re buying a result that hasn’t happened yet. Every agency has a brilliant case study or two. Ours included. What you actually need to know is whether they can do it again, for you, and whether you’ll be able to tell if it’s working before the contract’s up.
I’ve sat on both sides of this. I’ve pitched, and I’ve been pitched at by every kind of supplier going. The pitches that worried me most were the slick ones. So here are the 12 questions I’d ask. They work on any agency, including us, and if someone squirms at one of them, that’s your answer.
Questions about results
1. What did your last three campaigns actually do for the business?
Not the number of links. Everyone can count links. Ask what happened next: rankings, traffic, sales, enquiries, sign-ups. A decent agency can answer because it measured it. When The Bottle Club ran its Dream Job campaign with us, the numbers we talk about are the 600% sales lift and the 1,000+ newsletter sign-ups, more than the 115 links. When Better.co.uk grew revenue 60% with 58% less spend, that’s the headline, and the average domain authority comes second. If an agency can only talk in links, links are all you’ll get.
2. Can I speak to a current client?
Case studies are chosen to show the best work. A 10-minute call with someone who’s paying them this month tells you more than any deck. If they can’t find one willing, have a think about why.
3. How do you report, and how often?
Ask to see a real report with the client’s name blacked out. You want placements and their quality, the pages they link to, and movement in rankings, AI visibility and traffic, all in one place. If the report is a long list of links with a “potential reach” number next to each one, that’s what you’ll be getting too, and it tells you nothing.
4. How do you measure AI visibility?
This question didn’t exist three years ago and now it’s probably the most revealing one on the list. Your customers ask ChatGPT and Google AI for recommendations. Capgemini found 58% of consumers have replaced search engines with AI tools as their go-to for product recommendations. An agency working in 2026 should be able to show you which AI answers mention you today, who’s named instead, and how its work will change that. If the answer is a blank look, or “we’re looking into it”, they’re behind.
Questions about how they work
5. Who’ll actually be working on my account?
Ask to meet them before you sign. The people in the pitch are not always the people doing the work, and the people doing the work are the ones who matter.
6. Do you ever pay for links or placements?
The only acceptable answer is no. Paid links are against Google’s guidelines and can do lasting damage. Sponsored content should be labelled, and it isn’t digital PR. It also does little for AI visibility: Muck Rack found about 99% of the links AI cites come from non-paid sources. The machines can tell the difference even if your dashboard can’t.
7. Where do your ideas come from?
Good campaigns start with data and an understanding of what journalists in your sector are short of this week. Ask how they research ideas, how they test them before launch, and how many ideas they kill. An agency that never kills an idea isn’t testing them.
8. What happens when a campaign doesn’t land?
Every agency has campaigns that underperform. Anyone who says otherwise is lying or new. What you want to hear is what they do next: rework the idea, pivot to reactive, bring the next idea forward. Uswitch’s TV complaints campaign with us hit its KPI in 10 days with 103 media placements. Not every campaign does that, and an honest agency will tell you which ones didn’t and what it learned.
Questions about fit
9. Have you worked in my sector?
Some sectors have rules. Health, finance and alcohol brands need an agency that knows what can and can’t be said before it says it. Generic consumer experience doesn’t transfer as well as people think.
10. What will you need from us?
Data, experts, sign-off turnaround. Agencies that ask for these early are the ones planning to move quickly. Agencies that don’t ask are planning to blame you later.
11. What does it cost, and what’s included?
A fixed fee and a clear scope: how many campaigns, how many reactive hours, what reporting looks like, what costs extra. Vague scopes always resolve in the agency’s favour.
12. How will we know in three months whether this is working?
Agree the answer before you sign. Write it down. Then hold both sides to it. This is the one that stops a bad relationship drifting on for a year.
Red flags
A guaranteed number of links with no mention of quality or relevance. Reports full of “potential reach” and advertising value equivalents (those numbers were invented to make PR look like advertising, and they still don’t mean anything). No named people, or only senior people in the pitch. Vague answers about where links come from. Long lock-ins with no review point. And a subtle one: an agency that talks about “getting you in the news” rather than coverage, placements and results. The words people use tell you what they measure.
One client described us as “no faff, no nonsense, just proper work”. I’m not quoting that to show off (well, a bit). I’m quoting it because that’s the standard. Ask the 12 questions and see who meets it.




